Race matters
The Friday June 24th post at Waiter Rant got me thinking about something I've considered for some time. To summarize his post, he confesses to a misunderstanding that makes him appear racist.
Although I'm as white as they come, I feel somewhat qualified to address this, being married to a Chinese man, mom to two biracial daughters, and having lived as a minority in another culture for three years.
The truth is, I think we all harbor racist tendencies. For most people, these are probably not intentional or intended to be hurtful. As humans, we tend to make generalizations, and the easiest kind to make is based on what we see. Skin color is a noticeable visible difference between people. I will confess: when I am driving in downtown Indianapolis, if I see a black man near my car, I will automatically check to see if the car doors are locked. And I'm ashamed every time I catch myself doing it.
I even still make generalizations about Chinese people, though my husband sometimes encourages this with his own generalizations about his race. We both agree that Chinese (mainly immigrants, not Chinese born here) tend to be late.
I've been affected by racist attitudes myself. A minor one that drives me crazy is how Chinese (again, immigrants) tend to refer to anyone who is not Chinese as a "laowai" or "waiguoren", which means foreigner. This is true even here in the United States, where I will sometimes hear Chinese friends talking about some or other waiguoren. If my husband is in hearing range, he will quickly chime in and say "zheli, ni shi laowai!" (Here, YOU are the foreigner!). Sometimes I have used this in a teasing voice with my own Chinese friends when they do this. Some of them just look at me blankly as if they have no idea what I am talking about. My point is not who is or is not a foreigner; it's that Chinese tend to think of anyone who is not Chinese as an outsider. That is literally what "waiguoren" means...outside-country person.
Living in China I experienced some racist attitudes as well, most of them relatively benign. But one in particular I will never forget. A few days after we were married, we were traveling by bus to a nearby town to visit friends. A middle-aged man kept staring at us and finally asked Leo if he was my interpreter (something we got quite a bit). Upon hearing that I was his wife, he asked something very odd: he asked Leo if his parents had adopted me some years ago. From other stories I had heard, I knew that in Chinese culture, a blood son will sometimes marry an adopted daughter out of duty or pity. Before Leo could recover enough from his shock at the implication, the man went on to warn Leo that his life would be extremely difficult and full of problems because he had married me, a foreigner. At that point, Leo basically told him to shut up, because he had no clue what he was talking about.
Even though that incident stung, I eventually came to realize that the man's attitudes were based on ignorance. All racism is, really. Whether it's ill-intentioned or simply based on assumption and stereotype, racism exists because of lack of understanding of other races and cultures.
I don't discount that hate exists. I know it does, and sadly, it will as long as this world exists simply because evil exists. But as long as those of us who are merely ignorant of other cultures continue to try to learn, I do believe hate will be less.
And to anyone who is not white who may be reading this: please accept my apology for the times I act out of ignorance and fear of what I don't know or understand. I'm still learning, and I know I will be my whole life. But I'm trying. I think at least admitting that we each sometimes still have racist attitudes is the first step towards change, because if we don't admit this, we are saying we have nothing left to learn about people who are different from ourselves.
Although I'm as white as they come, I feel somewhat qualified to address this, being married to a Chinese man, mom to two biracial daughters, and having lived as a minority in another culture for three years.
The truth is, I think we all harbor racist tendencies. For most people, these are probably not intentional or intended to be hurtful. As humans, we tend to make generalizations, and the easiest kind to make is based on what we see. Skin color is a noticeable visible difference between people. I will confess: when I am driving in downtown Indianapolis, if I see a black man near my car, I will automatically check to see if the car doors are locked. And I'm ashamed every time I catch myself doing it.
I even still make generalizations about Chinese people, though my husband sometimes encourages this with his own generalizations about his race. We both agree that Chinese (mainly immigrants, not Chinese born here) tend to be late.
I've been affected by racist attitudes myself. A minor one that drives me crazy is how Chinese (again, immigrants) tend to refer to anyone who is not Chinese as a "laowai" or "waiguoren", which means foreigner. This is true even here in the United States, where I will sometimes hear Chinese friends talking about some or other waiguoren. If my husband is in hearing range, he will quickly chime in and say "zheli, ni shi laowai!" (Here, YOU are the foreigner!). Sometimes I have used this in a teasing voice with my own Chinese friends when they do this. Some of them just look at me blankly as if they have no idea what I am talking about. My point is not who is or is not a foreigner; it's that Chinese tend to think of anyone who is not Chinese as an outsider. That is literally what "waiguoren" means...outside-country person.
Living in China I experienced some racist attitudes as well, most of them relatively benign. But one in particular I will never forget. A few days after we were married, we were traveling by bus to a nearby town to visit friends. A middle-aged man kept staring at us and finally asked Leo if he was my interpreter (something we got quite a bit). Upon hearing that I was his wife, he asked something very odd: he asked Leo if his parents had adopted me some years ago. From other stories I had heard, I knew that in Chinese culture, a blood son will sometimes marry an adopted daughter out of duty or pity. Before Leo could recover enough from his shock at the implication, the man went on to warn Leo that his life would be extremely difficult and full of problems because he had married me, a foreigner. At that point, Leo basically told him to shut up, because he had no clue what he was talking about.
Even though that incident stung, I eventually came to realize that the man's attitudes were based on ignorance. All racism is, really. Whether it's ill-intentioned or simply based on assumption and stereotype, racism exists because of lack of understanding of other races and cultures.
I don't discount that hate exists. I know it does, and sadly, it will as long as this world exists simply because evil exists. But as long as those of us who are merely ignorant of other cultures continue to try to learn, I do believe hate will be less.
And to anyone who is not white who may be reading this: please accept my apology for the times I act out of ignorance and fear of what I don't know or understand. I'm still learning, and I know I will be my whole life. But I'm trying. I think at least admitting that we each sometimes still have racist attitudes is the first step towards change, because if we don't admit this, we are saying we have nothing left to learn about people who are different from ourselves.

12 Comments:
Ditto on the great post. Unfortunately, I think we're all prone to racial tendencies, whether we're white, black, Chinese, anything. Like you, I'm also ashamed to admit that I act how I do at times and would like to see a change for the better.
Very well written!
Great post Andrea...
I don't think children have a racist or bigoted bone in them, but adults teach them by actions, words and deeds to fear difference.
Such a shame.
I enjoyed reading your post!
This was very beautifully written. Thank you for sharing the story that hurt you. I'm sorry you had to go through that.
When I first started reading the song:
Colored People, by DC Talk popped into my head.
I grew up believing that I wasn't racist. In my family, we spoke of racial equality. I went to a high school where whites were a minority. I really, REALLY thought I wasn't racist at all.
But of course, I am. I don't know anyone who isn't.
I found out about my closet racism when I was shocked (*SHOCKED*) to think that someone I identified with... was black. Why that would make a difference, who knows?
After that, I started paying more attention to the things my family would say.
"I'm not racist," they'd start, followed by "but..."
"but, I think black women are ugly."
"but, I don't trust them [Asians]."
"but, I hate n*****s."
Actual quotes (the last being my more openly racist grandfather, who would still proclaim how racist he wasn't. Years later, Chris Rock did a routine that was almost word-for-word the same argument).
If you're white, and you can't identify with discrimination, come to Asia. I'm living in Japan now, where people are completely open with their racism. You'll see signs on businesses ("No foreigners"). People will move away from you (on a crowded train) if you sit next to them. People will stare. Children will touch the hair on your arms (I still don't know why; I know Japanese men with hairy arms as well). Here, it's racism without the shame.
I'm not sure which system is better. At least, here, we can talk about it.
Wow, this comment is much longer than I intended it to be. Sorry about that. :-)
idb for comments...great comment phoenix...I learned a lot...
Wow, Phoenix...it was bad enough in China when foreigners had to pay double (at least) what locals did for park admission, train tickets, hotels, etc. But "no foreigners" allowed...wow.
It's kind of weird: I think I wrote most of it off in China thinking, well, they're less developed, they were closed off to the rest of the world for so long, it's no wonder. They just need some time to catch up. But Japan doesn't really have that excuse. (Which probably means my attempts to justify it for China is yet another example of stereotyping...)
I came from the country and wouldnt really think I had racial biases, but I guess I kinda do. I left a good job to work for a minority business owner in the inner city one time. The pay was very good for the time. He treated me well to my face, but was a tremendous racist towards whites. He hated them because of skin color. In expanding his business I was renovating his office. It was filled with files of papers from the likes of Malcom X. Louis Farrakan (or however it is spelled) and others. Many were pure hate speech. He believed the CIA introduced aids to the inner city to wipe out the black population. I had a friend there that was a very, very well educated black man. He gave up his career as a professor to drive truck. He was a beautiful soul as was his wife. With all the evidence to the contrary, he cheered for OJ when the verdict of not guilty came out. He said it was because of all the injustice prior towards black. If a beautiful soul of a man, with a vast education can turn it off because of the past, I would say the tendency is in many of us, no matter how it is disguised, educated, tolerated or talked about. Could this be from ancient times and not trusting people who looked different than your own tribe?
Thanks for your further input and insight, Kitsune.
And I can relate (or rather, my husband can) to what you wrote about your fiance: Leo has said that his parents were originally worried that people would think he could not find a "nice Chinese girl" to marry. Not that they didn't like me, but they were worried about what other people would think. (We have a good relationship, though, and I don't think they care what other people think anymore.)
Kitsune
I'm in Fukui prefecture, near the Sea of Japan. I'm not in the military, I'm a teacher. Are you American? How often are you asked "How many guns do you have?"
Anyway, your "Walking alone at night" example is skewed, though. Race matters less than size and gender, in that instance. I wouldn't say all three have the same chance of harming me; I'm pretty sure I could defend myself against an old lady with a cane, and generally speaking women don't commit violent crime, MEN commit violent crime.
Why not ask if a giant WHITE man in a big leather jacket steps around the corner? Wouldn't you be similarly intimidated? Aren't black men statistically far more likely to be victims of violent crime than to be perpetrators? Aren't you statistically far more likely to be in a serious car accident than to be a victim of a violent crime?
Racism is a bv11$#!7 excuse for reasoning. You said "Making decisions based on race, especially when no other information is available, is very necessary." Please, give me an example of a situation where you know NOTHING about someone beyond their race, where making a judgement based on race is necessary or logical.
I invited Kitsune to come back over and give his take on racism in general and in Japan in particular, not to counter anything anyone said, but just to hear any experiences he had. I don't mind friendly discussion or even disagreement, but I would appreciate people not using terms such as "bv11$#!7 excuse" to describe someone's reasoning. I'm not trying to drive you off, Phoenix, and I appreciate your views as well, but I do prefer that my comments section not get unpleasant. Thanks.
andrea, this is obviously a very provocative post, I mean that in the best way, as provoking thought and discussion. I applaud your taking it on, and your sharing so openly about such a complex issue. Coincidentally when I was feeling so "writer's blocked" this past week (and still am), a lot of the old essays that I pulled out from my autobiography group days, were about race relations. You give me courage to maybe post something like that.
Post a Comment
<< Home